PDA

View Full Version : Superbowl ref



Go Aweigh2452
02-07-2006, 05:58 PM
yeah, I know... but here is a photo of the ref... now I know why he made those calls the way he did...

http://www.iboatnw.com/gallery/data/media/12/ref.jpg

Ok, it is true. The Seahawks did not play their "A" game. Stevens had the worst game of his career as a starter. Many of the calls against the Hawks were of the "questionable" variety.

But why weren't the Steelers subjected to the same "high" standards of excellence? Why were they not flagged for lining up in the neutral zone all game long (right defensive tackle)? Why were they not flagged for offsides for the crucial "holding" penalty when Stevens had caught the ball on the 2? Why no flag for offsides on the very next play? Why no calls on Steelers O-line for the same type of "holding" as the Hawks did?

I think it's time that the NFL steps in and takes some action against the referees. The officials of this game should be fined and FIRED! Their "questionable" calls determined the outcome of the SUPER BOWL! This is outrageous and should not be tolerated!!! The only honorable option to right this injustice is to replay the entire game! AND LET'S NOT FORGET THE NATIONWIDE APOLOGIES FROM THE OFFICIALS OF THE FIRST GAME!!!! They should be ashamed for disrespecting the Seahawks (who were robbed of a Super Bowl victory), the Steelers (who will never live down having the Super Bowl handed to them by the officials), and the fans (who had the great disappointment of watching the officiating train wreck)!

If the refs were going to call everything the Steelers' way, the league should have made them wear Pittsburgh jerseys and count them towards the 11 guys Pittsburgh is allowed to have on the field. I'm sorry, but some of those calls were inexcusable. I'm sure that on the Willie Parker touchdown, some Seahawk had the back of his jersey brushed slightly by a Steeler. Why didn't the refs call that and make the entire play come back, so the Steelers would have to punt? Because you shouldn't call nonsense ticky-tack stuff in the Super Bowl, especially on a game-changing play. Well in that case, I have a real hard time understanding how Darrell Jackson gets called for offensive pass interference for the equivalent of a soft NBA hand check. (Watch the replay again; he created absolutely no separation for himself on that play. He didn't alter the DB's motion at all.) I have a hard time seeing how Locklear gets called for holding when he stayed in front of the rusher the whole time, the rusher wasn't going to get to the QB anyways, and you have to practically tackle a guy to get flagged for holding these days. I have a really hard time seeing how Hasselbeck got flagged for an illegal block when he was successfully going for the ball carrier.

Forget the Roethlisberger "touchdown," because even if that hadn't been signalled a TD Pittsburgh most likely would have scored on the next play. Also, let's give credit where it's due; right after the Jackson TD was called back, another WR had the ball in his hands in the end zone and dropped it. Right after the Locklear holding call, Hasselbeck threw an interception. Jerramy Stevens treated the ball like it was kryptonite, Josh Brown was off target all night, Mike Holmgren's two minute drill couldn't get his team out of a wet paper bag, and the Steelers came through big when it counted. Even with that, I count 11 Seahawk points that were indisputably taken off the board due to calls that shouldn't have been made. This just happens to be the margin of victory. Throw in the importance of momentum and context (for example, if the score was 21-21, Seattle would have just gone for the field goal at the end rather than try whatever it was they were trying) and I can't help but conclude that Seattle was robbed in the biggest game in franchise history.

heymagic
02-07-2006, 07:22 PM
Well I heard tonite that the NFL reviewed the game footage and the refs didn't make any bad calls.... :?

Tedster
02-07-2006, 08:40 PM
Right on Doug I totally agree with you on this! :shock:

bradvo
02-08-2006, 08:53 AM
Got some bone heads on Boc now getting upset talking about the game- sheesh, most big games like this are up for discussion for awhile.
I also notice most the negative comments are from maryland residents.
Wonder why the heck it would tick them off? any ideas why the Colts left?
I am happy our team made it to the big dance, i wish the game had been played better, they had a good defensive first half. i was at work and had a tv going but it was still hard to watch it full time and keep focus on the plant. Made it home towards the end of 3rd quarter, it looked like hasselbeck had lost some of his composure, maybe he was trying to do to much himself .
I think the one play that really torked me was that TD in the first half that was called back for pushing off- that looked like BS call to me.
Brad

SomeSailor
02-08-2006, 10:35 AM
But hey...

They've had their best season ever... they have their best team ever... This gives them even more reason to be AWESOME next year. No doubt they're worth following and supporting. Their morale couldn't be better, their team couldn't be worth more and they only have to make it to Miami next year.

I've really enjoyed their composure through this as well. I know they have fines at risk if they trash talk the NFL over this, but they're conducting themselves like winners.

3788sam
02-08-2006, 01:31 PM
I agree with above- the Refs blew the really important calls and we can't go back and replay the game :(
But as Mike said this Hawks franchise is just starting to hit their stride in the last 3 years.
They keep improving, and how many teams can claim the won all their home games?
I'm look forward to next season :)

SomeSailor
02-08-2006, 01:44 PM
They'll have NO problem selling tickets next year...

Or attracting talent...

Randygh
02-08-2006, 03:14 PM
It would be very interesting to learn what the NFL is going to do with the officiating crew. After reviewing the game there should be some refs sent back down to high school ball games. There should also be changes in rules that allow for instant replay review. If there is instant replay, SEVERAL officials in the instant replay booth should be allowed to stop the game at any time there is an obvious bad call. It may slow down the game somewhat, but I think the officials in the booth would use their power of overturn very wisely, not excessively. We certainly don't want the NFL refs to go to the level of major league baseball umpires, but after Sunday's game, I'm not sure they refs are any better than the umps. :D

bradvo
02-08-2006, 03:41 PM
according to above post the NFL supports the Ref's as making no bad calls

I must be slow, just noticed the money in the ref's belt line in Pix above.

Go Aweigh2452
02-08-2006, 10:03 PM
just noticed the money in the ref's belt line in Pix above.


THAT made ME laugh... Well always next year... It was a great season and now we can all look for MARINER FEVER... a little MOJO... besides I enjoy baseball much more than football...

bradvo
02-09-2006, 02:00 PM
Just tansferred my moorage I paid for about a year ago at Bell harbor to April 22- we play Detroit. Not that i want to see that game that bad but I have to use that one night in Bell up at some point. I think this is 4 or 5th time I have moved the date??? I am losing count.
I do not like Bell harbor, but it does make for a nice BaseBall outing.
Actually the view from Elliot bay is much nicer. It really is spectacular looking over at the city at night.
To me Bell is noisy. It is a good people watching place though. I can sit up on the bridge watching people that are watching me. Last year I seen a guy stand in the same place for hours and hours, just looked up at the Cruise ship, he decided to walk away, made it about 4 to 5 steps- turned looked at the ship and went right back to the same spot again for hours.
I sat and wondered what his story was- obviously some mental issues but was curious all the same.
damn, wish I could be entertained that easy.
Brad

SomeSailor
02-09-2006, 04:04 PM
That's probably what someone on the cruise ship was saying about you.... "look dear... that same old guy is sitting down there... still staring at that other old guy..."

Go Aweigh2452
02-10-2006, 05:00 AM
"look dear... that same old guy is sitting down there... still staring at that other old guy..."


Don't ask, don't tell :oops:

bradvo
02-11-2006, 07:26 PM
quote-That's probably what someone on the cruise ship was saying about you.... "look dear... that same old guy is sitting down there... still staring at that other old guy..."

Actually they were probably saying, Golly Molly- If we owned a boat like his we would not have to be on this one with 2,000 other people. Now would'nt that be nice.
Brad

SomeSailor
02-12-2006, 07:43 AM
Probably. That's what I'd be thinking. :)